Probative Inquiry into the
2023 Financial Sector Stress Events
Limitations
This Probative Inquiry Preliminary Report records some portion of the findings we have gained through our ongoing efforts.
It is intended to identify what the evidence gathered thus far supports, where that evidence complicates the established public narrative regarding the financial sector stress events of 2023, and which questions require further examination. Its assessments are therefore provisional. They should not be understood as the final findings of Starling’s Probative Inquiry or to represent the conclusions of the Independent Expert Review that will follow.
Starling has reviewed a substantial body of public and nonpublic material and has interviewed senior Federal Reserve officials, current and former Board staff, Federal Reserve Bank personnel, former SVB directors and staff, and others with relevant knowledge. That evidentiary record is not yet complete. Starling’s document review continues, including its examination of Confidential Supervisory Information and other contemporaneous records bearing upon the supervision of SVB.
Nor has Starling completed every stage of its interview process. Where appropriate, the Inquiry employs a two-pass methodology: an initial narrative-led discussion, followed by document-anchored questioning designed to test recollections against contemporaneous records and to examine inconsistencies among different accounts. For some interviewees, that second stage remains outstanding. Starling has also conducted interviews with almost all currently employed members of the FRBSF Dedicated Supervisory Team responsible for oversight of SVB during the relevant period. As there has not yet been sufficient time to test and integrate that testimony fully, it is not treated substantively in this Preliminary Report and will feature in a subsequent report.
The testimonial evidence discussed herein also varies in form. Some interviews were captured through reviewed transcripts; others through contemporaneous notes or interview reports prepared by Starling staff. Even reviewed interview transcripts preserve retrospective accounts offered several years after the events under examination. Such testimony may provide indispensable evidence concerning institutional practice, communications, judgment, and decision-making context, but recollection is not equivalent to a contemporaneous record. Material assertions will therefore continue to be tested against documents, other testimony, and objective data wherever feasible.
Similarly, the competing accounts presented in this Report should not be mistaken for established findings merely because they correct an imbalance in the existing public record. The Barr, GAO, and OIG postmortem accounts did not involve interviews with SVB’s Independent Directors, while the accounts subsequently offered by those directors and by persons retained to assist SVB with risk remediation may reflect their own institutional predispositions. Those accounts are relevant evidence deserving consideration; they are not accepted uncritically.
Finally, Starling has yet to secure the cooperation of several former senior Board employees who have thus far declined Starling’s invitation to participate in the Probative Inquiry. Starling’s efforts to engage these individuals are documented in interim memos and briefings delivered to S&R in the course of the Inquiry.1, 2 Starling continues to seek their participation while pursuing alternative sources of evidence to mitigate any resulting gaps in the record.
Our Probative Inquiry is directed principally toward the design and operation of supervisory and risk-governance mechanisms. It does not seek to determine the personal motives of named individuals, assign responsibility, or conduct performance evaluations. Nor does this Preliminary Report attempt to establish that any single alternative supervisory action would necessarily have prevented SVB’s failure. The more tractable questions concern whether relevant risks were recognized, how they were interpreted and communicated, who possessed authority to act, and whether established supervisory processes reliably produced timely and proportionate responses.
Where the present record supports a conclusion, this Preliminary Report says so. Where it supports only an inference, raises a competing explanation, or exposes an evidentiary gap, the Report seeks to make that distinction clear. Subsequent stages of the Probative Inquiry will test these preliminary assessments, resolve contradictions where possible, and establish the completed evidentiary foundation upon which Starling’s Independent Expert Review and Recommendations for Reform will ultimately rest.
Join The Discussion
Sign in and be the first to comment.