The Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC) has levied a record KRW 1.63 trillion (~$1.22 billion) fine against 15 financial institutions for colluding in government bond auctions, as reported by Regulation Asia.
The penalties, which surpass the KFTC’s previous record fine of KRW 1.03 trillion against Qualcomm in 2016, target 10 securities firms and five banks. The KFTC also decided to file criminal complaints against seven institutions with the Serious Crime Investigation Agency. It said the institutions exchanged bidding information or coordinated rates and volumes in 150 of 345 Treasury bond auctions held between January 2020 and June 2023, reaching direct agreements in 145 of them. Employees communicated via phone calls and Telegram messages shortly before bidding deadlines. In one instance, they agreed on a 3.7% bidding rate in just five seconds.
The KFTC found that firms compiled lists of competitors' contact information and documented communication protocols in work manuals. This ensured that the illicit information exchange continued seamlessly when personnel were replaced. The KFTC said these practices artificially raised yields, restricted competition, and ultimately increased the government's borrowing costs.
The financial industry has pushed back against the enforcement action, characterizing the behavior as routine information sharing. Several penalized firms argue that such communication is a common practice and a defensive measure necessary to fulfill their market-making obligations as primary dealers.
The industry is also challenging the KFTC’s methodology for calculating the penalties. The regulator based the fines on the winning bid amounts — totaling approximately KRW 54 trillion in relevant sales — rather than operating revenue. KB Securities received the largest individual fine (KRW 332.2 billion), followed by NH Investment & Securities (KRW 242.8 billion) and Mirae Asset Securities (KRW 214.8 billion). Most of the penalized securities firms are preparing to file administrative lawsuits challenging the KFTC's decision.
The Korea Financial Investment Association warned that the sanctions could severely constrain brokerages' liquidity, disrupt government bond issuance, and damage South Korea's external credibility just as its Treasurys were added to the World Government Bond Index (WGBI).
Join The Discussion
Sign in and be the first to comment.