Report

Probative Inquiry Preliminary Report

The Starling Advisory Group has released a Public Exposure Draft of its Preliminary Report, detailing initial findings-of-fact developed in the course of our Probative Inquiry into the 2023 Financial Sector Stress Events and the failure of SVB.

cover image.png

About this Preliminary Report

This Preliminary Report presents the initial findings of Starling's ongoing work, drawing on interviews with current and former senior Federal Reserve officials and supervisory staff as well as an extensive review of public and confidential documentary evidence.

The report is being released as a Public Exposure Draft to invite review, challenge, and informed public comment as our Probative Inquiry continues. At Starling’s discretion, valuable feedback will inform our ongoing efforts, shape our future reports, and contribute to the important public good towards which we aim.

Accompanying the Public Exposure Draft as Addenda are:

  • A statement from the Independent Directors of SVB.
  • Analytical Account of the Failure of Silicon Valley Bank as Viewed in Public Data (Charles River Associates)
  • Social Media Analysis re The Failure of Silicon Valley Bank (Charles River Associates)
Image - Banker Texting - Shutterstock_744565771.jpg
Download

Download the Probative inquiry Preliminary Report

Starling's Probative Inquiry Preliminary Report is available here as a Public Exposure Draft. Download the Full Report as a PDF.

Download PDF

Preliminary Report: Public Exposure Draft

Preliminary Report

Opening Letter

Opening Letter from Starling Advisory Group Founder & CEO, Stephen Scott.

Image - Hourglass - shutterstock_2638894435.jpg
Preliminary Report

Summary Timeline

Image - Tickbox - shutterstock_1398130301.jpg
Preliminary Report

Key Findings

Seven Key Findings from the Preliminary Report

Image - Hand Laptop Network - sm- shutterstock_2147055985.jpg
Preliminary Report

Executive Summary

Introduction

Image - Consolidation - Shutterstock_2324546705.jpg
Preliminary Report

Mandate

Image - Review Regulators.jpg
Preliminary Report

Scope

Image - Steps to Goal - Shutterstock_2184280179.jpg
Preliminary Report

Methodology

Image - blocks bottleneck limited - shutterstock_2773845549.jpg
Preliminary Report

Limitations

Probative Inquiry Preliminary Report

Image - SVB Collapse - Shutterstock_2278996817.jpg
Preliminary Report

The Established Public Narrative

Image - Auditing - Shutterstock_1754977007.jpg
Preliminary Report

Examining the Established Public Narrative

Image - Reports Stacked Paper - Shutterstock_709205902.jpg
Preliminary Report

The Barr Report

Starling's review of the 2023 "Review of the Federal Reserve's Supervision of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB)" overseen by past-VCS Michael S. Barr.

Image - Why - Shutterstock_1359905924.jpg
Preliminary Report

Reexamining the Established Public Narrative

Image - Bank Capital - Shutterstock_2274263253.jpg
Preliminary Report

1. A “textbook case” of mismanagement

Read
Image - Employee Shortage - Shutterstock_2210900063.jpg
Preliminary Report

2. "Weaknesses in corporate governance"

While SVB clearly struggled with governance weaknesses, Starling's Probative Inquiry did not find evidence that the Board or management was complacent or non-responsive to risk and compliance concerns.

Read
Image - Collapse - Shutterstock_160902620.jpg
Preliminary Report

3. "Supervisors did not fully appreciate the bank's vulnerabilities"

Supervisors identified significant weaknesses in the SVB's governance and risk management but they did not appreciate how those weaknesses made the bank vulnerable to the run.

Read
Image - Stopped Progress - Shutterstock_2345272707.jpg
Preliminary Report

4. "They did not take sufficient steps"

Once supervisors recognized the vulnerabilities at SVB, they did not move swiftly to apply corrective measures.

Read
Image - disorganized - shutterstock_1963011826.jpg

5. An overly "deliberative" supervisory approach

Fed supervision relied on a deliberative, consensus building process which emphasized accuracy and comprehensiveness over action.

Read
Image - Turning Point - Shutterstock_2537725725.jpg
Preliminary Report

6. "A shift in the stance of supervisory policy impeded effective supervision"

Read
Image - Social Media - Shutterstock_1728918238.jpg

7. A run, "unprecedented" in its speed, "fueled" by social media

Read

Conclusion

Image - Hand Laptop Network - sm- shutterstock_2147055985.jpg
Preliminary Report

Conclusion

Read
Image - Work in Progress - Shutterstock_792442291.jpg
Preliminary Report

Next Steps

Read
Image - Staff Survey - Shutterstock_2161188361.jpg
Preliminary Report

Interviews Conducted

Read
Image - Stacks of Papers - Shutterstock_565403764.jpg
Preliminary Report

Documents Reviewed

Read

Addenda