The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has commenced civil penalty proceedings against the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), alleging the bank unlawfully overcharged tens of thousands of business customers because of systemic governance and compliance failures spanning nearly two decades.
ASIC alleges CBA’s CommBiz terms and conditions were misleading and failed to accurately disclose fees for Direct Debit and Direct Credit payments. Customers were told they would pay a single fee for payments to or from third-party accounts, but ASIC says CBA also charged an additional, undisclosed “contra leg” fee. Between November 2020 and May 2025, around 42,000 customers, many of them small businesses, were allegedly overcharged approximately A$8.5 million. The issue dates to CommBiz’s launch in 2006 and has resulted in more than A$26.4 million in remediation payments to roughly 93,000 customers.
ASIC’s court filings describe repeated warnings and control failures. Customer complaints about the charges date back to at least 2015, while a 2016 internal audit found CommBiz customers were being charged more than disclosed and rated the control environment “red” and “unsatisfactory.” Corrective action was required, but ASIC alleges the overcharging continued until May 2025. CBA also allegedly failed to properly investigate or escalate at least 13 serious complaints. In 2022, a customer-relations specialist raised a systemic concern about transaction charges, but CBA closed the matter on the basis that there was “no bank error.”
ASIC also alleges that successive governance and compliance measures failed to identify or resolve the issue. These included new incident-management processes, document controls, executive oversight, and a billing control that relied on internal billing information without determining whether charges were contractually authorized or adequately disclosed. An internal investigation began in 2024 after a senior manager warned that CBA might be seen as “double charging,” but the matter was initially assessed as not reportable to ASIC. CBA first reported the investigation to ASIC in June 2025, followed by a July notification identifying potential misleading conduct.
“We allege Commonwealth Bank broke a basic promise to its business customers, many of them small businesses, that the fees it told them they would pay were the fees they would actually be charged,” said ASIC Commissioner Alan Kirkland. “ASIC will continue to take action where banks don’t have the systems and processes in place to deliver on the basic promises they make to their customers.”
CBA has acknowledged the proceedings, apologized to affected customers, and said it had self-identified and reported the matter, while disputing aspects of ASIC’s allegations. ASIC is seeking declarations, financial penalties, adverse publicity orders, and an independent expert report confirming compliance with orders concerning CommBiz fee controls.
Join The Discussion
Sign in and be the first to comment.